Saturday, May 28, 2011

Char Gul: The barber of Kabul

Char Gul: The barber of Kabul

Char Gul

Related Stories

Throughout decades of turbulence, the barber at Kabul's military training academy kept his shop open. Char Gul has cut the hair of generations of Afghan soldiers who went on to positions of power or to perish on the battlefield. The BBC's Bilal Sarwary met him.

It is not a lucrative profession, but Char Gul's vocation was as a barber and he has witnessed more than 50 years of tumultuous change in Afghanistan, cutting the hair of soldiers at Kabul's training academy.

"My father wanted me to go to school. But I didn't like books, exams or teachers. All I wanted to do was play the doal [an Afghan drum] and cut hair," the 69-year-old said.

Start Quote

I succeeded in giving crew cuts to two dozen soldiers in one hour flat!”

Char Gul Kabul army barber

At the age of 19, Char Gul decided to enrol in the army and travelled from his home village in Wardak province to the capital.

There was instant recognition for his talent at the Kabul Military Training Centre - but as a barber not a soldier.

"As a test, I was told to give haircuts to recruits. Perfection with speed is what an army strives for," he said.

"I succeeded in giving crew cuts to two dozen soldiers in one hour flat!"

Thousands of soldiers have entrusted their locks to his shears, including the country's current defence minister - who still gets the occasional haircut from Char Gul.

As the country lurched from one crisis to the next, Char Gul says he just kept on cutting hair. Throughout it all, the military academy continued to turn out soldiers.

Many of his customers rose to high ranks in the army, some became generals and a few even ministers. Many others were killed in combat.

Army family

But he remained a confidant for nervous recruits with little idea of the brutality in store for them. They would talk about their problems with him.

"Solders talk about... how they miss home, they talk about their girlfriends and wives. They talk about fatigue, war and sometimes, ask me questions about the war, about KMTC," he said.

Soldiers who go on to become senior officers stay in touch with him and Char Gul says this is his true home now.

Char Gul playing the Doal drum Char Gul plays the doal drum at the graduation parades for the soldiers

"I was recently asked if I wanted to retire. But I said, I will retire the day I die. This is my family now.''

Char Gul has yet to meet Hamid Karzai, but he has met a host of other Afghan leaders over the years.

The country's last king, Zahir Shah, and former presidents Daud, Taraki, Amin, Babrak Karmal and Najibullah were all introduced to Char Gul when they came to inspect the military - he played an important role in keeping the soldiers' hair neat and trim.

When he started in the 1960s, the academy was recruiting and training soldiers to serve under Zahir Shah.

"The king was a gem," he recalls.

"I met him when he visited the KMTC to attend a parade. He was extremely soft-spoken and his eyes were full of kindness. His rule was the golden phase for Afghanistan."

Start Quote

Many things have changed. But this barber shop remains the same”

Char Gul

But the king was deposed a decade later by his cousin and brother-in-law Daud Khan. There began a period of coups and intense instability and then Soviet troops invaded.

"The arrival of Russian troops was the beginning of a bloodbath and misery in Afghanistan which still continues," Char Gul says.

By 1991 he had experienced six rulers but he continued to serve until the Afghan army was dissolved after the collapse of the last Moscow-backed president, Najibullah, and the emergence of the US-backed Afghan Mujahideen.

Like many Afghans he found the ensuing five years of civil war, followed by another six of Taliban rule, the darkest of his life.

"There was a government in every corner of Kabul," he said. "Once I was stopped by one of the groups and nearly killed but my days were not over yet."

He kept a low profile and avoided working during the time of the Taliban.

The academy fell out of use as a military training centre. It became part of the front line during the civil war and under the Taliban it was the ministry of defence. When the US ejected the Taliban in late 2001, they refurbished the entire building.

Char Gul cutting hair Char Gul teases recruits as he cuts their hair
General customers

"I went back to my old job again," Char Gul said with a smile.

One senior officer says of the barber: "The most amazing thing is how he managed to keep his job throughout his career."

"Many things have changed. But this barber shop remains the same," says Char Gul.

As soon as new recruits enter the academy they come into contact with him - the familiarity and intimacy between soldiers and barber are clear to see.

"Sit up straight!" teases Char Gul as he prods a young soldier from Wardak on the side of the head. "You're in the army now."

Char Gul has also been given the role of playing the doal during the annual graduation ceremony.

"Soldiers, young and old, break into dance when I play the drum," says the barber. "This gives me a sort of hope.

"If a simple thing like music can bring us together, the love for our country, which is stronger and deeper, can surely keep us together in difficult times."

Source

Wednesday, May 25, 2011

Gaza: Egypt 'to open Rafah crossing to Palestinians'

Gaza: Egypt 'to open Rafah crossing to Palestinians'

Palestinians protest at the Rafah crossing, Gaza (15 May 2011) Palestinians protested at the Rafah crossing to mark the anniversary of the creation of the state of Israel

Egypt is to open the Rafah border crossing into Gaza permanently to most Palestinians from Saturday, Egyptian state news agency Mena has said.

Gaza has been under blockade since 2007, when the Islamist Hamas movement took control of the territory.

Under ex-President Hosni Mubarak - ousted in February - Egypt opposed the Hamas administration and helped Israel to enforce the blockade.

Israel says the blockade is needed to stop weapons being smuggled into Gaza.

The Rafah crossing will be opened permanently from 0900 to 2100 every day except Fridays and holidays, beginning Saturday 28 May, Mena said.

"Palestinian women of all ages will be exempted from visas as will men under 18 or over 40," Mena reported.

Rafah is the only crossing into Gaza which bypasses Israel.

The BBC's Jon Leyne, in Cairo, says it is unlikely Israel will welcome the move, although it has been easing its own restrictions on its crossings with Gaza.

Significant shift

The transitional military government said last month that it intended to open the crossing permanently.

Our correspondent says the announcement illustrates the more independent-minded foreign policy likely to be adopted by Egypt's new rulers.

Egypt's co-operation in blockading Gaza was one of the most unpopular policies of former President Mubarak, he adds.

Last year, Israel eased restrictions on goods entering Gaza, but significant shortages in the territory remain.

Mena said the decision to open Rafah was part of efforts "to end the status of the Palestinian division and achieve national reconciliation".

Egypt's post-Mubarak government has already helped broker a reconciliation agreement between Hamas and the Fatah faction, which governs the Palestinian West Bank. Israel has condemned the deal.

Under Mr Mubarak, Egypt upheld its unpopular peace treaty with Israel and opposed Hamas in the internal Palestinian power-struggle.

Hundreds of smuggling tunnels run under the Egyptian border with Gaza.

The blockade has been condemned as a form of collective punishment of the population of the Gaza Strip because of the hardships it causes.

In 2010, the International Committee of the Red Cross said the blockade was a clear violation of international humanitarian law.

Gaza map

Source

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Commentary

This is the result and effect of giving the people of Egypt Democracy.
By removing the vile dictators in the middle east that have been enslaving its people for decades, you now allow the blossoming of a peaceful coexistence and the development of a just society.

The people NEVER asked their government to punish the Palestinian people, and yet, with overwhelming disagreement, the unjust Pharaoh of Egypt did so.

Punishing people, especially innocent people, for political reasons is unacceptable and would never allow a human being to sleep comfortably at night.

The only ones who have been sleeping comfortably while the Palestinians were being tortured were the stone hearted, unjust, monarchs of the region.

If every Israeli could see the damage this blockade was having on innocent children's lives, there would be near unanimous agreement to have the blockade ended immediately.

Today is a day we should celebrate, when light finally shines on the shadowed past of pain and suffering. Today the healing starts for the innocent civilians.

Bacteria-rich hailstones add to 'bioprecipitation' idea

Bacteria-rich hailstones add to 'bioprecipitation' idea

Hailstones The layers representing the build-up of hailstones can be seen in cross-section

Related Stories

A study of hailstones has found large numbers of bacteria at their cores.

The find lends credence to the "bio-precipitation" idea, which suggests that bacteria are actively involved in stimulating precipitation.

The bacteria have protein coatings that cause water to freeze at relatively warm temperatures.

Researchers at the American Society for Microbiology meeting suggest bacteria may have evolved to use the water cycle to facilitate their own dispersal.

The micro-organisms that can be found in precipitation such as snow have been studied since the 1960s.

One bacterium that has appeared in many contexts is Pseudomonas syringae, which expresses a protein on its surface that encourages an orderly arrangement of water molecules.

That in turn acts as a "nucleation" site, stimulating the formation of ice at temperatures far higher than those normally required.

So effective is P. syringae at the task that it is used in a commercially-available mixture for snow machines.

In nature, the ice that P. syringae stimulates can damage the walls of plant cells, allowing the bacterium to feed on the cells' interiors.

Only in recent years, however, has a wider role for the bacterium's strategy started to become more clear.

In 2008, Brent Christner of Louisiana State University reported finding significant numbers of bacteria in snow found around the world.

'Intriguing'

Now, Alexander Michaud of Montana State University has added to the idea, having collected hailstones on the university campus following a major hailstorm in 2010.

Pseudomonas syringae bacterium P syringae bacteria are well-known "catalysts" for ice formation

He analysed the hailstones' multi-layer structure, finding that while their outer layers had relatively few bacteria, the cores contained high concentrations.

"You have a high concentration of 'culturable' bacteria in the centres, on the order of thousands per millilitre of meltwater," he told the meeting.

The bacteria are known to gather together in "biofilms" on the plant surfaces and can form bacteria-rich aerosols in forest canopies - aerosols that can rise on updraughts, eventually stimulating precipitation in clouds at temperatures far higher than would be required if soot or dust served as the nucleation sites.

Dr Christner, also present at the meeting, said the result was another in favour of the bio-precipitation idea - that the bacteria's rise into clouds, stimulation of precipitation, and return to ground level may have evolved as a dispersal mechanism.

"It's an interesting idea that's been thrown around for decades but only recently has the data accumulated to support it," he told the meeting.

"As a microbiologist, this idea that... an organism could piggy-back on the water cycle I find just intriguing.

"We know that biology influences climate in some way, but directly in such a way as this is not only fascinating but also very important."

Source

Saturday, May 21, 2011

Alan Grayson: Republicans Show True Colors About Medicare

Alan Grayson: Republicans Show True Colors About Medicare


The science 'X Factor' with a 1bn euro prize

The science 'X Factor' with a 1bn euro prize

ADVERTISEMENT

Fet 11 - "a unique conference on visionary, high-risk and long-term research in information science and technology" - is a place where big ideas get noticed.

And the big prize is for two EU-funded projects to be given up to 100m euros per year for 10 years to conduct their research.

Dan Simmons looks at the six finalists and some of the wackier ideas at the conference.

Source

Israel PM defiant over Obama border proposals

Israel PM defiant over Obama border proposals

Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu rejects pre-1967 border agreement call

Related Stories

Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu has rejected US President Barack Obama's call for peace with the Palestinians based on pre-1967 borders.

After tense talks at the White House, a defiant Mr Netanyahu said Israel was prepared to compromise but there could be no peace "based on illusions".

Mr Obama, who formally adopted the principle on Thursday, admitted there were "differences" between the views.

But he said such differences were possible "between friends".

In his speech to the state department on Thursday, Mr Obama stated overtly for the first time that the peace talks should be based on a future Palestinian state within the borders in place before the 1967 Middle East War.

"The borders of Israel and Palestine should be based on the 1967 lines with mutually agreed swaps, so that secure and recognised borders are established for both states," he said.

This proposal has been a key demand of the Palestinians in the negotiations.

But speaking in the Oval Office after their meeting, Mr Netanyahu flatly rejected this proposal, saying Israel wanted "a peace that will be genuine".

"We both agree that a peace based on illusions will crash eventually on the rocks of Middle Eastern reality, and that the only peace that will endure is one that is based on reality, on unshakeable facts."

'Demographic changes'

Israel was "prepared to make generous compromises for peace", he said, but could not go back to the 1967 borders "because these lines are indefensible".

Start Quote

The Israeli prime minister couldn't be clearer: At the moment there is no basis for new talks and he won't buy the president's plans”

He said the old borders did not take into account the "demographic changes that have taken place over the last 44 years".

An estimated 500,000 Israelis now live in settlements built in the Palestinian West Bank, which lies outside those borders.

The settlements are illegal under international law, although Israel disputes this.

Mr Obama said there were obviously "some differences" in the "precise formulations and language" used by Israel and the US, but that this "happens between friends".

He did not bring up the matter of the borders in his joint conference with Mr Netanyahu.

But he said Palestinians faced "tough choices" following the recent reconciliation deal between Fatah, which runs the West Bank, and Hamas, which governs Gaza and still denies Israel's right to exist.

Mr Obama said true peace could only occur if Israel was allowed to defend itself against threats.

The BBC's Paul Adams in Washington says that while notion of a peace agreement based on 1967 lines is not news, Mr Obama has clearly angered Mr Netanyahu by formally adopting it.

Mr Netanyahu has come under increasing pressure as world figures and organisations, including American's partners in the Middle East Peace Quartet, EU, UN and Russia - lined up to back Mr Obama's position.

Arab League chief, Amr Moussa, also called on President Obama to remain committed to the plan.

But in the absence of a viable peace process, it is unclear what will come of US-Israel talks, says our correspondent.

Map

Source

~~~~~~~~~~~

Commentary

I'm glad that at least there is a clear cut position and that Israel is being confronted on all sides by this logical first step for peace.

There is no alternative at this point for any Palestinian state to exist without the 1967 borders.

Such a state would be a crippled West Bank and Gaza, a shadow of Palestine's former self. That's why such a deal is unacceptable to the Palestinian people and even to the weak boned Fatah.

At the end of the day Isreal needs to remember that it truly stole all the land it currently sits on and to be speaking as if it owns claim to it all and that it decides all the terms is very proud and very haughty.

Similar situations occurred in Northern Ireland and the violence still hasn't fully disapated after years of peace talks and unneeded deaths.

A country should never steal or usurp the land of another. Injustice will always lead to pain.

The defense of innocent people and the work of justice to reclaim land rights of those it was taken from, is now what the peace talks should focus on.

Sadly I'm not optimistic about them turning to those relevant topics.

Wednesday, May 18, 2011

The tent that turns into concrete in less than 24 hours

The tent that turns into concrete in less than 24 hours

Help

The past 12 months have seen a remarkable number of humanitarian crises with earthquakes in Japan and New Zealand and deadly tornadoes in the southern US being among the most recent.

Among new innovations which could help relief efforts is a fabric shelter that, when sprayed with water, turns to concrete within 24 hours.

Invented by two engineers while at university, Concrete Canvas allows aid teams to construct solid structures in emergency zones quickly and easily.

Will Crawford and Peter Brewin showed BBC News how the concrete tent is put together and spoke about what inspired them.


Source

Saudi woman seeks to put women in the driving seat

Saudi woman seeks to put women in the driving seat

Najla Hariri Najla Hariri says there is no law against women driving, only society's convention

Related Stories

A Saudi woman has taken to the road in a direct challenge to the country's ban on female drivers.

Najla Hariri started driving around Jeddah last week. She is believed to be the only woman regularly driving in a Saudi city.

The 45-year-old says she was inspired by the protests taking place elsewhere in the Middle East.

"Enough is enough", she told the BBC as she drove around the city. "I have the right to [drive]."

Ms Hariri holds a driving licence from both Egypt and Lebanon from her time living abroad, and also has an international licence that she uses when she drives in Europe.

Start Quote

In this society I am a little bit brave - I am not scared”

Najla Hariri

"There is no law against women driving. It's society's [convention] that says women are not allowed to drive."

'Not scared'

The mother of five has the support of her husband and says her daughters and their friends are very proud of her.

She knows, however, that she could be stopped at any moment by the police.

"In this society I am a little bit brave. I am not scared," she says.

Najla Hariri's driving licence Najla Hariri says she was inspired by the Arab Spring protests

In some desert areas of Saudi Arabia, women are understood to drive occasionally, but it is virtually unheard of for a woman to take to the road in a major city.

Opponents of women driving argue that it's safer for females to have a male in the car with them, and that they are honouring their women by sparing them the strain of driving.

"They are lying to themselves," replies Ms Hariri forcefully. "It is safer for women to drive themselves. We have four million foreign drivers [in the country] and we'd like to get rid of them and drive ourselves."

Ms Hariri admits she did not want to be at the vanguard of efforts to give women more freedoms.

She returned to Saudi Arabia two years ago and was tempted to start driving immediately.

She found herself stuck at home with two cars but no driver, as her husband and eldest son were both away. "But I waited for the right time; I waited for other ladies to [go first]," she says.

Start Quote

We are focusing on spreading the word - women here don't know their rights”

Najla Hariri

As no-one stepped forward, she has decided that now is the moment.

"Before in Saudi, you never heard about protests," she says.

"[But] after what has happened in the Middle East, we started to accept a group of people going outside and saying what they want in a loud voice, and this has had an impact on me."

Facebook campaign

Najla Hariri's challenge to Saudi society is part of a wider effort for greater female participation in the whole of society.

A Facebook page is encouraging women to come out and drive on 17 June.

Other women are pushing for the right to vote in municipal elections scheduled for September, while there are also calls for women to get permission to sign legal documents.

Aalia, a 19-year-old university student, is co-ordinating some of the online reform efforts.

"We are focusing on spreading the word, raising public awareness," she says. "Women here don't know their rights."

Source

~~~~~~~~~~~~

Commentary

Lets look at the middle east a second, shall we. So there are sanctions from Iraq to the western shores of Africa in the Ivory coast. Sanctions for human rights and a number of other issues.

But when it comes to Saudi Arabia.... where are the sanctions America?

Where are the sanctions on human rights in the one place they are threatened the most?

When a woman has virtually no rights in a country run by the dangerously extreme Wahabbi sect, why does no one in America speak up?

Right now Syria is being sanctioned for what it's doing to it's protestors, and yet Saudi does it on a daily basis to every woman in it's borders. Why the double standards?

Oh yea, i forgot.... Oil.

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

Pakistan: Bin Laden death exposes complex militant ties

Pakistan: Bin Laden death exposes complex militant ties

Policemen and paramilitary forces stand at the scene of a suicide bomb blast in Dir, northwest Pakistan April 4, 2011 Militant attacks have killed thousands of people in Pakistan over recent years

The presence of Osama Bin Laden on Pakistani soil has once again raised questions about the links between the country's security establishment and jihadi militants.

It is an issue that has long concerned Western leaders who provide Pakistan with billions of dollars of aid each year and expect, in return, full co-operation in the US war on terror.

In July last year, British Prime Minister David Cameron said that he could not tolerate a situation in which Pakistan was able to "look both ways" so that it could promote the export of terror.

And just last month, US Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Adm Mike Mullen went on Pakistani television and openly accused Pakistan's main intelligence agency, the ISI, of having links with a powerful tribal group believed to facilitate the movement of Taliban fighters from Pakistan into Afghanistan.

The ISI, Adm Mullen said, had a "long-standing relationship" with the Haqqani network.

The fact that such senior political and military leaders are openly voicing their suspicions about Pakistan reflects their frustration that a decade into the US war on terror, the Taliban movement in Afghanistan is strong and growing stronger.

'Unmatched record'

The biggest question just now is whether Pakistan knew Osama Bin Laden was living in its country.

Start Quote

Shaukat Qadir

There is no way Osama Bin Laden could come here without the ISI's knowledge”

Shaukat Qadir Retired brigadier

Many Pakistanis familiar with the way the security establishment works think it is very likely the ISI did know.

"There is no way he could come here without the ISI's knowledge," said retired Brig Shaukat Qadir.

"You see this particular house had been raided... This house has been under suspicion all along."

Others insist that the ISI did not know and argue that its track record of catching militants proves it has no desire to hide them.

Assad Munir, another retired brigadier, was working for military intelligence and the ISI before and after 9/11.

He was based in north-west Pakistan and led the search for al-Qaeda and Taliban leaders.

"We got hold of the maximum people, who went to Guantanamo. I think we got hold of more than 260 people between 2001 and 2003," he said.

"We have the record. I don't think anyone else can match it."

It is a complicated situation and outsiders are often baffled by Pakistan's aggressive attitude towards some militants, and apparent tolerance of others.

Jihadis, after all, are causing havoc in Pakistan. With an average of more than one suicide bombing every week, 35,000 Pakistanis have died since 9/11.

'Countering India'

The key to understanding Pakistani policy is to appreciate the distinctions between different types of militant groups.

Some, such as the Pakistan Taliban, are attacking targets within Pakistan - including security force personnel. The Pakistan army is consequently fighting the Pakistan Taliban hard. It has lost thousands of men in doing so.

Taj Mahal Hotel in Mumbai on November 27, 2008 Pakistani-based militants have been accused of planning the 2008 Mumbai attacks

But other Pakistani-based groups are focused on the war in Afghanistan. Pakistan has long been preparing for an American defeat in Afghanistan and wants to have a good relationship with whatever government takes over once the Americans have left.

For Islamabad, there is a lot at stake.

Pakistan used to think of Afghanistan as a place that gave it strategic depth. A friendly government in Kabul allowed it to concentrate its military forces on the border with India.

Islamabad is highly concerned that Delhi, which has given more than $1bn of aid to Kabul in recent years, is getting a foothold in Afghanistan. Countering Indian influence in Afghanistan is a top Pakistani priority.

Since the post-Hamid Karzai government will almost certainly include elements of the Taliban, Pakistan has an interest in maintaining good relations with the Afghan Taliban leader Mullah Omar.

Mullah Omar has repeatedly said he does not want his part of the Taliban to attack targets inside Pakistan.

Furthermore, if Pakistan allows Punjabi militants, for example, to fight in Afghanistan then it means they cannot cause any problems at home.

Find out more

You can hear the full report on Assignment on BBC World Service Radio on Thursday, 12 May 2011 at 0905BST or on Crossing Continents on BBC Radio 4 at 1100BST . You can also listen via the BBC iPlayer or by downloading the free Crossing Continents podcast or Assignment podcast.

But it is not just Afghanistan. There have even been cases of groups thought to have close links with the ISI launching attacks in India itself.

For example, the deaths of more than 170 people in Mumbai in November 2008 were blamed on the Pakistan-based militant group, Lashkar-e-Taiba.

Under huge international pressure, the Pakistani authorities put the founder of the organisation, Hafiz Saeed, under house arrest, but a few months later released him.

Other members of the group were taken into custody in Pakistan but none of their trials have been processed.

Abbas Nasir, a former editor of the Dawn newspaper, says there are elements of the state that want some militants to be set free.

"People have been killed, the murderers have been arrested, and then released without charge at the behest and the instigation of the security services," he said.

"They perceive India as the biggest enemy that they have. And think they need the jihad, the international jihad forces, to protect them and to reinforce their foreign policy, be it in Afghanistan or Kashmir."

'Impunity or death'

The state's lack of determination to ensure the conviction of some jihadis has also been apparent in the investigation into the murder of former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto.

Start Quote

People have been killed, the murderers have been arrested, and then released without charge at the behest and the instigation of the security services”

Abbas Nasir Former editor of the Dawn newspaper

Despite strong evidence that the Taliban carried out the assassination, and the arrest of five suspects, their trials have been delayed on various pretexts.

Jihadis involved in less well-known cases also escape justice but for different reasons.

Fearing reprisals, eyewitnesses and judges are reluctant to give evidence against or to convict jihadis.

In addition, the legal system is stacked in favour of militants. For example, possession of any amount of explosives - including suicide vests - is a bailable offence.

Many police officers have stories about jihadis being let off.

Senior superintendent of police Akbar Nasir Khan, for example, once arrested a man for attacking a politician's house in Peshawar with a rocket launcher.

He arrested him, seized various weapons, and found eyewitnesses who had seen the accused with the rocket launcher.

But three months after the case went to court, the man turned up in Akbar Nasir Khan's office and suggested they have cup of tea.

The court had released him on bail on the grounds that he was not a threat to public security.

The failings of the judicial system mean that, increasingly, for street level militants, it is a case of impunity or death.

Some police officers are so frustrated by the failure of the courts to convict jihadis that they say that rather than arrest suspects they now kill them.

One police officer in Karachi told me he had killed 22 militants.

"They always say the same thing", he said, putting his finger on the middle of his forehead.

"They say don't break my body. Make it quick."

Source

~~~~~~~~~

Commentary

Pakistan does it's utmost to interject in the way of Justice and to allow death to occur inside and outside it's borders.

As a result it's people live day in and day out with suicide bombings and power cuts.

Until it's people rise up and revolt for a new government, this current Pakistan is a joke. It is a mecca of corruption, greed, and injustice.

As far as how much the ISI knows about it's borders and it's capital; to assume that it was totally ignorant of Osama's prescence, just miles from the capital, is absurd.

The ISI hid him there, under their wings, until America found the damning trail of bread crumbs.

Why are Americans so angry about petrol prices?

Why are Americans so angry about petrol prices?


Petrol pump

Rising petrol prices in the US are expected to be one of the key issues in the 2012 presidential election. But Americans still pay half of what Europeans fork out on the forecourt. So why is it such a big deal?

Whatever bounce President Barack Obama has received from Osama Bin Laden's demise, there is a widespread belief that his fortunes at the ballot box in 18 months will be decided by two things.

Gas and jobs.

Bar chart showing petrol prices in US and six other countries

While the latest employment situation appears to be mixed - figures last week suggested both jobs and jobless rose in number - the president will be closely monitoring feelings on the forecourts of petrol stations across the US.

A survey published on Sunday by Lundberg said the price of a gallon of petrol (a US liquid gallon, not imperial), had hit a nationwide average of $4 (£2.40), just 11 cents short of the record high in 2008 at the height of the financial crisis.

There has been some respite since the weekend with prices of gas, as it is known in the US, reportedly falling by five cents in some places, but the anger felt by drivers shows no sign of abating.

At Tyson's Corner Center, a huge shopping mall in northern Virginia, motorist after motorist said it was hurting them in everything they did - the commute, the weekly shop or the school run.

And worryingly for the faltering economic recovery - and the president - they said they were being forced to cut back on other spending to pay for gas.

What US motorists say...

Orgil Ganbold

"I notice the gas prices increase a lot because I spend about $200 a month on it. I've been driving for 10 years and this is the worse I've known it," says Orgil Ganbold, 29, pictured in his Jaguar.

"I earn the minimum wage and half my pay cheque goes on gas," says Aimen Idris, 20, who works in a shopping mall. "So I'm not eating out and not going out as much."

"It doesn't affect me so much because I live near where I work. But my friends talk about it a lot and my daughter hasn't visited since spring break because she can't afford the gas," says Gloria Burtrago, 50.

"Of course it's hurting, it's $1.25 more than a year ago. I'm considering buying a bike and cycling the four miles to work," says software engineer Pedro Alvarado, 25.

Drivers speaking from Tyson's Corner, northern Virginia

The issue is so important that it is rarely out of the news, with TV bulletins continually monitoring the prices and analysts always on hand to discuss the consequences. Polling suggests it is one of the biggest concerns among the electorate.

In Europe, prices are roughly double the US due to the tax, but the anger is not so palpable, and almost certainly not about to influence elections. A protest planned in the UK at the weekend drew only a fraction the number expected.

So what is it about the American relationship with gas that makes it such an important issue?

Americans use their cars more, so the pain is greater. They have, on average, a longer daily commute than all Europeans, except Hungarians and Romanians. Public transport is generally poor so many Americans have no alternative but to drive.

But there is also a symbolic significance about gas that goes to the heart of what America is.

It signifies mobility, freedom and personal liberty, says Dan Neil, motoring correspondent on the Wall Street Journal.

"Anger is probably more tied up with a wider sense of decline and also a loss of privilege.

"Cheap gas has been one of the prerogatives of the American Empire so people have become accustomed to it in a way which is somehow associated with our ability to wield our will around the world.

Why are gas prices rising in US?

  • Crude oil more expensive due to global demand for cars
  • Ethanol price increasing for same reason, makes up 10% of gas
  • Unrest in the Middle East can affect supply
  • Sales tax and credit card fees are fixed percentages and so compound these increases
  • Speculation by investors has impact day to day but not much over long term

American Petroleum Institute

"We're mad because we've spent a lot of money in the Middle East and made a lot of enemies and defended a lot of tyrants and still gas prices go up."

And knowing that the British pay double won't make Americans feel any better, he adds.

"Americans are not aware of what the rest of the world pays for gas. We are a very big, inward-looking domestic market. We don't watch soccer, we don't watch French movies and we don't really care what the Europeans pay for their gas.

"It's a very big country and the entire infrastructure is predicated on scandalously cheap energy. Everything we do is big - business, agriculture, entertainment.

Start Quote

The reason why the British public are more sanguine [than Americans] is firstly because that's their nature”

Quentin Willson Motoring expert

"Where we live, where we play, all of that is predicated on cheap gas, so when the price of gas goes up, it really cuts to the heart of the American way of life."

The long-term solutions, he says, would involve a huge investment in rail, an overhaul of the infrastructure and a change in mindset - not events that happen overnight.

In the UK, there is no sign that the nationwide fuel protests by lorry drivers 11 years ago will be repeated soon, despite petrol now being double the price.

At the weekend, a protest at an oil refinery in Stanlow, near Cheshire, failed to draw the 1,000 vehicles expected. Instead there were little more than 100.

"The reason why the British public are more sanguine [than Americans] is firstly because that's their nature," says motoring expert and broadcaster Quentin Willson.

"And secondly, the fuel protests of 2000 will never happen again because the cops have got wise to it. Haulage companies have been told that if they start blocking refineries, they'll lose licences."

View from the Netherlands

  • Price rises are definitely reported - the oil industry puts out a consistent stream of press releases to keep the issue in the news - but there is no huge outcry
  • At current prices, Americans spend about $2,600 on transport fuel per head, almost twice the European average of $1,400
  • Petrol is relatively expensive and diesel relatively cheap in Netherlands, probably because we do not have a car industry, but do have a huge trucking industry

Mr Dings is the Dutch director of T&E which promotes sustainable transport across Europe

But the anger is there, says Mr Willson, who led a delegation to Downing Street to complain about fuel duty, and people are near breaking point.

They are stopping him in the street to complain, he says, and some are having to choose between food and fuel.

Petrol sales are down by a fifth in the last year and breakdowns due to tanks running empty are up by 17% in the same period.

"We're on the cusp of social unrest," he predicts.

But petrol is unlikely to define a UK election. In the US, gas prices are a bellwether of consumer confidence, says Mr Neil, and will be more influential in 2012 than Bin Laden.

Republicans blame Obama for gas prices, while Democrats blame oil companies, and they're both wrong, he says. It's more complex, to do with US oil refineries running at capacity and speculators driving up the price of crude oil.

Line graph showing price of petrol in the US and price of crude oil

The one key driver behind rising prices is the price of crude oil, says John Felmy, chief economist at the American Petroleum Institute.

It's increased in price by about $1.20 a gallon since August, he says, driven by increased global demand, especially in China and India, where more and more people are driving cars.

Zipcode lottery

  • Chicago, Illinois, $4.50
  • Los Angeles, California, $4.26
  • Seattle, Washington, $4.04
  • Boston, Massachusetts, $4.04
  • Newark, New Jersey, $3.87
  • Tucson, Arizona, $3.62

Source: Lundberg Survey

The portion of tax imposed by the federal government has not risen for several years, but there's a big variation between states, illustrated on the CNN website, which reflects the duties imposed by states.

Rising oil prices mean bigger profits. Last month, Texas-based oil company Exxon announced profits of $10.7bn (£6.4bn), up 69% on last year. There was an outcry, given the pain felt by motorists.

Mr Obama has said he wants Congress to end the $4bn in annual tax breaks for the oil and gas industry.

Although this won't affect prices at the pumps, he wants the money to be invested in clean energy sources.

But some of his critics say he should be doing more to liberate restrictions on American drilling.

Either way, as long as American drivers are feeling the pain at the pumps, the president will be wary of how that pain will play out at the polls.

Source